Upon leaving Tilt West’s November, 2017 roundtable on Curators, Collectors, and the Shaping of Art History, which opened with Aspen Art Museum Curator Courtenay Finn’s astute comments, I was struck by the need to delineate the role that visionary collectors and curators play in the writing of art history. The visionary collector is not simply a consumer but an organized and strategic participant in the field at large.
Only days after the Tilt West conversation, we read the news of the painting Salvator Mundi, attributed to Leonardo da Vinci, coming to auction and being sold for a staggering amount — the largest price tag on an artwork to date — a whopping four hundred and fifty million dollars for what might very well be the work of a different artist altogether. The art world and general public started and continue to spin and speculate. This is a politically charged discussion. Under an emerging paradigm in the global museum system, Saudi Prince Bader bin Abdullah bin Farhan al-Saud, an associate of the progressive Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, made the historic acquisition of Salvator Mundi, on behalf of a young, still formulating, encyclopedic museum, the Louvre Abu Dhabi. The goal of this growing collection, as with others, is to assume a role as a catalyst in the shaping of art history. The debate over the provenance of Salvator Mundi rattles this effort.
Historically, great collections in cities like New York, London, and Paris have had the advantage of colonialism and its operating structures working on their behalf. Let’s take an example from the French. Upon the invasion of Egypt in 1798, Napoleon Bonaparte initiated the Description de l’Égypte, a series of publications cataloguing all aspects of ancient and modern Egyptian culture and natural history. These were completed by 1829. At the same time, another researcher and art collector — archaeologist, egyptologist, architect, and writer Emile Prisse d’Avennes — spent nineteen years documenting the art and architecture of ancient and Islamic Egypt. These endeavors resulted in encyclopedic registries of material culture from places that the French occupied and extracted from in order to build their own national collection. The market for art objects and artworks in our contemporary moment, a post-colonial time, operates differently. These differences shape the ways in which new museums, new centers of study and learning, and new hubs of knowledge and writing develop collections and programming.
During the Tilt West roundtable, one participant made reference to the seminal 1874 Impressionist exhibition in which thirty artists displayed 165 works at the photographer Nadar’s former studio at 35 Boulevard des Capucines. This example provides an historic context for the potential bond between dealer, collector, and curator — a bond that can support artists individually, and sometimes, as we know from the story of this group, collectively. Paul Durand-Ruel was one of two French art dealers who developed markets in Europe and the United States for the artists who came to be called the Impressionists and also the Barbizon School. This stunning example of a visionary collector continues to resonate in the ambitions of today’s collectors. Durand-Ruel’s commitment to new ways of interpolating pressing questions about experiments in painting is intriguing. Why was he willing to lose his shirt over these artists? Decades later, the prescient collector, Peggy Guggenheim befriended and supported a coterie of artists who lead the charge of Modernism as it has been canonized. Guggenheim’s support extended beyond simply developing markets for these artists; she also built institutions for intellectual exchange. Her legacy, alongside those institutions that bear her name, is writ large on the cityscapes of Venice, New York, Bilbao, and Abu Dhabi.
On November 28, 2017, Holland Cotter wrote an extensive and revealing article about Louvre Abu Dhabi, the new home of Salvator Mundi. He describes in vivid language an architecture that begs a visit, and an intelligent approach to building a collection given the constraints of the market (i.e., what objects are currently available). Equally important, Cotter conveys the institution’s perspective on collecting in a way that points to a prescriptive vision of the future. The challenges of articulating the cultural patrimony of an emerging nation in futuristic terms are a complex problem to solve in this era when pillage and plunder have been deemed unethical. Instead, nationally-celebrated museums like those in Abu Dhabi must negotiate long-term loans with partner institutions, such as the Paris Louvre, and carefully, slowly, assemble objects and works that articulate a view of culture in ways relevant to broader sweeps of humanity than previously seen. Cotter expresses his delight in the curatorial strategies used to animate a new and growing collection with an eye to building visual associations that transverse and transcend time and space. This is an important museum for any curator or collector to see, for it imagines a poetic future. I am curious to know its plans for disseminating its art historical perspective.
There are lessons to be learned from the depth and integration of different arms of art’s ecosystem. A consummate visionary collector, Patricia Phelps de Cisneros, announced this year that a significant selection from her world-class collection of Latin American art would be distributed among museums with the capacity to steward these works. The Denver Art Museum is among the illustrious group, not only because of its stellar Spanish Colonial collection, but also because the collection is being historicized, theorized, and curated by a leading scholar in the field. The DAM’s Frederick and Jan Mayer Curator of Spanish Colonial Art, Jorge Rivas Pérez, by no coincidence, worked for many years at the Colección Patricia Phelps de Cisneros (CPPC). Patricia Phelps de Cisneros has had the vision to cultivate and support leading scholarly curators who have assumed significant roles globally. The well-thought out decisions of a collector of her caliber is an example that can serve emerging, powerful collectors, such as those behind the Louvre Abu Dhabi and others, like the Sharjah Art Foundation in the United Arab Emirates. These institutions are participating globally through the collection, creation, and presentation of visual art. Their reach will be furthered through endowing positions in museums, universities, and art schools throughout the world.
Agnes Gund has always been understood as a force for good through her collecting and philanthropy. This year, however, by a singular, focused decision, Ms. Gund has risen above the clutter and noise of the art world and set a visionary example. In many an interview you will find her expressing a deep attachment to different artworks she has acquired, and in some cases, when working with living artists, that attachment extends to the artist. Her decision to sell her prized 1962 Roy Lichtenstein Masterpiece to fund an initial donation of one hundred million dollars to establish the Art and Justice Fund has begun to inspire a much-needed shift among collectors. The reaction among peer philanthropists has been a steady flow of contributions to this necessary program through the cultivation of a group of founding donors. The donation was not made lightly. Ms. Gund has made the decision to translate Lichtenstein’s Masterpiece into a bold new effort to end mass incarceration. Through a coherent relationship with the Ford Foundation and Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors, this visionary collector has transformed the reach and power of this pop art painting. The humor of this choice is also not lost, for the painting’s fortuitous messaging imagines the artist’s future success in the New York art market.
The recent decisions of Colección Patricia Phelps de Cisneros and Agnes Gund point to a bright future. This brings me back around to the Louvre Abu Dhabi and its stunning potential as a beacon for experimental, challenging curatorial work, through strong bonds with visionary collectors. I can see a new approach to art history, embodied by the Louvre Abu Dhabi’s approach to collecting and programming, which prioritizes the layers and complexities that inform cultural exchange and economies over the millennia and moving forward. Shifting perspectives conveyed through research, writing and discourse, partnered with visionary collectors, have the possibility of overriding prevailing art historical canons, whether the result of hegemonic imperialism or market-based speculation. I see the possibility of cultural institutions collaborating with collectors, curators, scholars and thinkers, to galvanize around intellectual and ethical stakes that are gaining traction in our fragmented, pluralistic artscape, allowing for a multiplicity of art histories to be written.
"Ultimately, America’s answer to the intolerant man is diversity." — Robert Kennedy
I remember the first time I noticed someone like me included in a mass market advertisement. The springy curls jumped out at me from the Target clothing ad on the side of a shopping cart, spurring me to literally gasp in surprise and excitement at the bouncy hair, coiled and untamed. My hair, usually the butt of sitcom jokes and “before” pictures on miracle conditioners, was being presented as intentional and welcome! Occurrences like this led me to understand that one of the most important requirements for a sense of inclusivity is representation. We need to see ourselves with seats at the various tables serving community. We have a hard time imagining that which we cannot readily observe. Every imagination utilizes the status quo as an inception point, and when our own image is not represented, we are left void of personal inspiration. This level of isolation in a society deeply scars those who experience it.
I know when to change my hair to something more socially acceptable to increase my chances of inclusion. I’ve oddly eschewed braces my entire life to avoid inclusion on some aesthetic goal that society has set for me. It’s easy to identify which vocal tone might get me included in a date/meeting/social invitation, which readily-digestible artistic representations might garner me invitations to stages and microphones. As a mixed black woman, born of the working/middle class, I have yet to decipher which code or collection of characteristics might more properly attain my equity in this society.
"Dominator culture has tried to keep us all afraid, to make us choose safety instead of risk, sameness instead of diversity. Moving through that fear, finding out what connects us, reveling in our differences; this is the process that brings us closer, that gives us a world of shared values, of meaningful community." ― bell hooks
Although the media and the public as a whole are currently engaged in a national conversation around racial politics, we each can’t help but see it all through our own unique lens. Our personal experience gives texture to, and finds context within, the larger national narrative. We are all reflecting on that which we feel we’ve been offered or allowed access to, and that which we’ve not.
Despite the boundary-crossing love of my parents, my family is not exactly a melting pot. Being mixed black, the shape of my extended family has been completely defined by each person’s ability, or lack thereof, to embrace racial inclusion. Years and holidays and memories have been missed because of an idea born before I or my siblings came along — an idea that was supposedly rectified by the “Loving vs. Virginia” case of 1967. Many of us are stunned by the reactionary attitudes of some of our fellow Americans. Didn’t we already have these conversations, march these marches, and fight these fights? No court case could ever change a heart, though, and now we’re learning how rigidly a mind can cling to dangerous relics of the past.
One snapshot of the challenges around inclusivity in our divided nation is my small-town, Iowa-bred aunt cooing over pictures of my very brown and very liberally-raised daughter, while simultaneously posting pro-Trump memes about the horrors of single motherhood and sensationalist stories about black-on-black violence. What a Thanksgiving this would make (if we ever spent one together, of course)! Can there be room in an inclusive national dialogue for a mindset that literally denies the humanity and agency of others? We can include you so long as you remove some of those limbs, take up less space and require less consideration.
"We are less when we don’t include everyone." — Stuart Milk
This month, on November 9th, Apple released its first diversity report under a new VP of Diversity and Inclusion. The same day, Forbes ran an article discussing the measurement of diversity and inclusion, touching on some of the common quandaries one comes across when contemplating the subject. Even if we can define the basic metrics of diversity, how do we measure the more subjective experience of inclusion? And how do we assess the impact of broader representation as it relates to social cohesion and a deeper understanding of others?
It’s interesting how these words — diversity and inclusion/inclusivity — so often travel together. In the recent Tilt West roundtable, prompter Suzi Q. Smith defined Diversity as the condition of having or being composed of differing elements, and Inclusivity as an intention or policy of including people who might otherwise be excluded or marginalized. Whether America is viewed as a melting pot or a mosaic, the contact points at which we lean into or pull away from our differences with others define our national culture and our trajectory as a people.
Each of us must decide how we will interact with others whose political, spiritual, or economic beliefs differ from our own. We all know how distasteful it can be to ask about a friend’s politics. At this point, however, some find delving into these personal stances less distasteful than breaking bread with someone who (at least in theory) does not believe in a perceived “outsider’s” right to a plate. These are painful and taxing conundrums, tearing families apart in many cases. In this increasingly dire time when so many use fear as a weapon, how uncomfortable are we willing to be for the sake of one another? Find a safe level of discomfort and explore it. Seek and celebrate differences. Question your security. If we are not able to recognize (and literally re-cognize) our personal interactions and attachments, any further conversation about inclusion is futile.
"No culture can live if it attempts to be exclusive." — Mahatma Gandhi
A participant in Tilt West’s September roundtable on Art and Activism said afterward, “What you are doing is activist: getting people together in person and in conversation in a free flowing and non-hierarchical way.” Tilt West aims to catalyze the cultural conversation in the greater Denver arts community. To that end, and as a continuation of our conversation on Art and Activism, we invite you to join artists and arts organizations across the country in participating in a Day of Art Action on January 20, 2018.
The Day of Art Action is the brainchild of filmmaker Laurie Anderson and a group that Tilt West has joined, called The Federation. The event is a response to pressures on arts organizations in the current environment. The Day of Art Action will celebrate the idea that art unites; it will showcase the fact that art is in every community across the country. Artists and art organizations are invited to mark the day in whatever way they deem appropriate and to post their activities on social media.
To sign up to participate, and for a free, downloadable, Day of Art Action toolkit, please go to the Federation’s website, www.wearethefederation.org, and see the attached flier. We hope to see broad participation by Denver area artists and arts organizations. You are also welcome to contact us at info@tiltwest.org.
To mark the Day of Art Action on January 20th, Tilt West will be hosting a special roundtable discussion on The Lure of Spectacle in Politics and Art.
Traditionally, spectacle derives its appeal from its visual power to engage an emotive response in the viewer — a notable goal of art. Although spectacle is endemic to theater and performance (Aristotle’s Poetics, for example, discusses the proper arrangement of dramatic elements to elicit an emotional response from the audience), the use of spectacle crosses virtually all artistic genres.
With the advent of technology, philosophers and social thinkers from Roland Barthes to Marshall McLuhan observed a temporal and spatial separation between the spectator and the spectacle. For Guy Debord, the political and consumer apparatus hijacked the artistic vehicle and created a situation in which authentic social life became replaced with its representation.
With the dominance of social and digital media and the presence of algorithms in today’s society, we’ve experienced another leap in the iteration of spectacle. This roundtable will discuss the use and abuse of spectacle — its potential for both destructive and generative ends as applied to political and artistic expression in the current environment.
Stay tuned for more information on this upcoming roundtable in the coming weeks.

This August, Tilt West facilitated a roundtable discussion on Development, Displacement, & the Arts, at RedLine’s 48 Hours of Socially Engaged Art & Conversation Summit. Lydia Hooper of Fountain Visual Communications was there to make a graphic recording of the discussion (pictured above).
Denver is changing. Mayor Hancock told radio host Ryan Warner that, “[t]he vibrancy of this city is to have a diversity of residents. We don’t want to ever be known as a city of just those who have.” Jonathan Thompson, High Country News, Nov. 24, 2014. I grew up in Denver in the 1980s and 90s. I then lived on the coasts for much of the 2000s before returning to my hometown a few years ago. I’m both a native and a transplant: I appreciate the city’s history, and I am not opposed to its changes. But we need to reflect on not just what we see changing across Denver, but how those changes are occurring and what the pace and character of those changes says about us as a community.
One of the conclusions of Tilt West’s August 2017 roundtable discussion of “Development, Displacement, and the Arts,” was that Denverites claim to support the arts and artists, but the incentives in our local economic and political systems instead encourage rapid growth over thoughtful and inclusive change. I believe that we need to transform cultural capital into political capital in order for Denver to change in a way that incorporates art and diversity. Before sharing a few ideas on how to do that, I’d like to explore the difference between gentrification and artistic revitalization, and the different types of capital.
I have always struggled with the term “gentrification” because it tends to elicit a visceral revulsion. It is clearly more than just “look, another coffee shop has moved in on the corner” and “look, more condos!” It includes the idea that a formerly eclectic neighborhood is now more homogenous, a formerly low to mixed-income neighborhood is now expensive and out of reach for “regular folks” and, most pointedly, a formerly ethnic neighborhood is now full of white people who might never have set foot in the area when it hosted 50+ year old family businesses, but are everywhere now that the boutiques and craft breweries have arrived.
One of the roundtable participants challenged us to distinguish between gentrification and artistic revitalization, which is what we saw initially in an area like RiNo where older, neglected industrial warehouse spaces were reclaimed by artists for workspaces and galleries. His point was that gentrification displaces while revitalization enhances; gentrification replaces while revitalization reinvents; and gentrification forgets while revitalization remembers and incorporates the past and the existing neighborhood character. That very revitalization, however, often creates what some reluctantly admit is “cultural capital,” which in turn raises property values and ultimately invites investment of monetary capital to a neighborhood.
So, let’s talk about capital. A lot of the Tilt West discussion revolved around the tension between the inherent value of art, which breeds cultural cache in a given geographic area and raises property values, and the money that is ultimately drawn into that area from the outside by those who want to trade their dollars for cultural capital. The prompter of the roundtable, Yong Cho, noted that “one of the great values of artists is they challenge the status quo, they make you think, they push you forward.” I agree and consider this to be an intrinsic value of artists and the art that they produce. Once that intrinsic value converts into cultural capital, however, money, an item of extrinsic value, often follows. So, where once we saw low-priced collaborative live-work spaces used by artists, we now see high-priced townhomes; where once there was an informal gallery, now there is a craft brewery; and so on.
I would argue that we need to monetize the cultural capital that artists build, because that cultural capital is the reason that developers are attracted to the area in the first place. Both as compensation and to retain the cultural cache of a neighborhood, new development needs to provide affordable living and working spaces for artists, and to integrate art in projects in more than a “token” way.
These sorts of changes require different incentives in our local economic and political systems. Unfortunately, items of intrinsic value like art are rarely fully valued until they are threatened or gone. The extrinsic value of outside money is winning. The only way to change things is for artists to organize and raise their voices: make demands of elected officials; change the incentive structures; tap into the idea that we don’t just want a bland city of those who have; make the point that eventually people won’t flock to the city or its developments if it’s all shopping malls. Citizen engagement is an important part of the process. If we want to foster and maintain inclusive neighborhoods, newcomers — both artists and developers — must engage with the community that is already in place.
We aren’t going to stop new development. Nor do I think we should. Artists can, however, demand a seat at the table when affordable workspaces and housing are threatened. Everyone is busy but being heard requires getting out in front of new site plans, development proposals, and urban planning initiatives. It’s much harder to be effective once decisions have already been made. My hope is that the same artists who challenge the status quo, make the rest of us think, and push us forward with their work will put some of that energy and creativity toward engaging with our local elected and business leaders regarding the value that art and artists bring to the broader community, beyond making a neighborhood “hip” and “up and coming” for the next project that displaces them.

This May, Tilt West facilitated a roundtable discussion on Art, Community, and Conflict, at Colorado Creative Industries’ 2017 Summit in Breckenridge. Lydia Hooper of Fountain Visual Communications was there to make a graphic recording of the discussion (pictured above).
In 1881, Paul Gauguin wrote to Camille Pissarro, “There is a theory I have heard you profess, that to paint it is absolutely necessary to live in Paris, so as to keep up with the ideas.” The artist who ultimately paints his greatest work on an island in the South Pacific, pondering if he needs to be among art masters to become one himself, is beyond ironic. Historically, however, primary markets — both economic and intellectual — were highly centralized. Propinquity allowed critics to argue, enabled artists to see the work of contemporaries, and turned collectors into patrons. Ideas were produced in places like New York or Paris and diffused outward. Is this still true today? Can an artistic community feel isolated in a virtually connected world? Certainly, even a city dweller hiding behind a smart phone can feel as isolated as an artist in the Roaring Fork Valley. It boils down to the phenomenological claim that one does not really exist unless acknowledged by an outside source. In a 2011 New York Times article about the California arts festival, Pacific Standard Time, an art critic and university professor called the festival “corny” in its title, scale, and extended time line, ending with, “it’s the sort of thing that Denver would do.” The general exclusion of the Rocky Mountain region from the national art market discussion does affect more than the psyche of artists in Denver.
Denver may not be as isolated as Tahiti, but the city’s creative contributors are marginalized when one considers who actively participates in the international art world. In Sarah Thornton’s book Seven Days in the Art World, she notes that the art world is not just a place where people work but reside full time, “a ‘symbolic economy’ where people swap thoughts and where cultural worth is debated rather than determined by brute wealth.” As Thornton highlights, “great works do not just arise; they are made.” How an artist moves from a small Denver art gallery to a museum wall is not simple or a matter of luck. That promotion requires the support of dealers, critics, curators, and collectors.
So when only a few Denver art galleries participate in one or two mid-size international art fairs, that is a concern. When many of the top art collectors in America have homes in Aspen, and the world-renowned Aspen Art Museum never shows a Colorado artist, we have a problem. When editors based in New York City, like those at ARTnews, voice concerns on professional panels about disappearing local reporters and papers from periphery art cities, killing the informational pipeline, we should pay attention, because these are the reasons our artists worry. Artists see the growth of Denver and maneuver through the consequences of urban development, but the benefits to our creative community are lagging.
According to economists Uri Gneezy and John List, people support the arts and give to charities for three reasons: the warm-glow of helping others, self-interest (tax benefits or investment), and a motive called follow-the-leader. An example of follow-the-leader is when a potential donor is incentivized to donate due to a charity starting a fundraising campaign with a high seed level. This seed money motivates the next donor for many reasons: presumably the initial donor did the research into the legitimacy of the charity; a donation places the individual in a desirable social circle; and the presence of the seed money appeals to donors who are risk-averse. Despite the recent population growth that places Colorado as one of the top seven fastest growing states and despite the increased wealth that accompanies such growth (have you seen home prices?), artists continue to complain about the lack of funding through typical avenues such as government grants, private foundations, and corporate sponsors. According to the Colorado Business Committee for the Arts, artists are right. Nearly one-fifth of new money coming into the state’s cultural sector last year was in the form of federal grants. Philanthropic giving to the arts increased in 2016, but only enough to put us on pace with national trends. That means in Colorado there is no follow-the-leader impact…yet. How does the cultural sector reach new audiences in a measurable way to grow the purse?
One solution proposed at the Tilt West roundtable on Regional History and Potential was a renewed focus on the work. As the theory goes, when the art has substance and is worth protecting, the money will show up. Tell that to van Gogh. It is a shared principle in the art world that nothing is more important than the art. As author Sarah Thornton points out “some people believe this; others know it’s de rigueur.” What I hear — and agree with — is that we should embrace solutions like developing Aurora as a potential art center and relax the grip on a neighborhood like RiNo that is pricing everyone out. We should also acknowledge that discourse does not occur when we use assumptions as evidence, and better discourse is the necessary foundation for Denver to be a formidable art force. Raise your hand if you want to read on Saturday instead of ski. That is what must happen if Denver wants to take the stage as one of the next great American art cities.
The 2013 book, Art Cities of the Future: 21st-Century Avant-Gardes proposes a broadening definition of an art capital with cities like Bogotá, Johannesburg, and Vancouver demonstrating successful and unconventional infrastructures. The text highlights the tremendous potential for a place like Denver while bypassing the problematic discussion of whether our city will be the next great version of a city that already exists. For example, Redline and Lighthouse Writers Workshop provide professional development and public service that many American cities find enviable. The money raised through the Scientific and Cultural Facilities District tax is one major reason Denver’s creative community quickly recovered after the great recession and continues to add jobs to our cultural institutions. Gallery directors testify that museum curators from the state regularly walk into local galleries to see Colorado artists. Curator Jose Roca in Art Cities of the Future notes that the emerging art capitals had “no outside intervention,” and the local scenes thrived without the pressures of the art market, not in spite of its absence. It is a powerfully persuasive argument that Denver does not have to follow existing urban blueprints; it may still carve an unexpected, yet smart and satisfying route.
Can an artist make it out here in fly-over country? Those bi-coastal dealers and curators are too busy with their noses in their laptops to look out the airplane window. Nothing to see down here.
But Colorado artists have become well known in the art world. In the 1960s, Betty Woodman taught ceramics at CU Boulder. Every summer she had a garden sale of her pots. One day, she decided she was making art and began a long climb that culminated with her becoming one of just a handful of living artists to show at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. She was the first living woman artist to do so.
Today, media artist Mark Amerika seems to spend more time on an airplane than in his CU Boulder classroom. He exhibits and lectures frequently in Europe, Asia and Australia. He’s always in touch with who and what’s going on in new media. The Denver Art Museum is becoming recognized nationally for its exhibits. The CU Art Museum was first in the nation to show Enrique Martinez Celaya and Tibetan Diaspora artists. Craig Ponzio’s collection of monumental sculpture is well known. Kent and Vicki Logan are recognized for their support of contemporary art and their cutting-edge collection.
It can be done. You’re not likely to be the next Marilyn Minter or Mark Bradford any more than you can be Beyonce or LeBron James, but we can grow satisfying careers and influential institutions here.
Colorado’s arts infrastructure is supportive. The SCFD sales tax adds over fifty million dollars annually to the arts in the seven metro counties. There’s nothing like that anywhere in the country. There are now more art dealers than ever before. Dealers do go to art fairs. They are on the web. The Denver Art Museum regularly hangs local artists with big-name international works. MCA Denver has solo exhibits by Colorado artists. The CVA is an excellent space. Under Blake Milteer, the Colorado Springs Fine Arts Center mounted several in-depth exhibits of Colorado artists.
Denver’s Rule Gallery cleverly opened an outpost in Marfa, Texas — a magnet for art mavens who come to see Donald Judd’s Chinati collections — and maybe Denver artists, too. Black Cube’s Cortney Stell brilliantly arranged to show Joel Swanson and Laura Shill in Venice during the run of this year’s Biennale.
That’s a lot of support. Still, Denver isn’t New York or LA or Berlin.
We all need to be part of the conversation.
What to do? Can we make Denver an art capital? I think so. Start with yourself. Did you see Joel Swanson at the MCA? Did you scratch your head? And Marilyn Minter? Your sort of art? How about Tony Ortega’s big painting at the DAM or Mary Ehrin’s feather pieces? Find other artists and art supporters who saw the same shows and talk about what you saw at your own “Cedar Bar” and thrash it out over some beers.
If enough of us begin to talk with each other about the art that’s out there at artists’ studios, galleries, and museums, then some very interesting conversations will take place. Connect and reconnect. Spread the word. Send those opinions out into the art world — to curators, gallerists and collectors. Through this communication, artists and their work will become a more central part of the larger regional community.
Denver can become its own “art capital.”
It starts with us.
In its third roundtable discussion, Tilt West took on a topic that has captivated the world since humans invented mechanical objects — technology and the body. One doesn’t have to look very far to find evidence of this fascination: a quick Google search turns up 410,000,000 results including TED talks, magazine and newspaper articles, academic papers, blogs, textbooks, pop culture icons, and the list goes on.
When discussing technology and the body, one of the first things that comes to mind is the cyborg. The cyborg, a souped-up fictional human with mechanical parts, came on the scene in the mid-nineteenth century (in a short story by Edgar Allan Poe) and has shown considerable staying power since. Cyborgs appear again and again in art, books, television, plays and movies, yet one more indication of the human fascination with technology and the body. But the cyborg has given us more than proof that people are keenly interested in technology and the body; the cyborg has allowed us to think about what it means to be human. Add to that the unendingly complicated question, “Should we enhance humans with technology?” and you have a ready-made debate on your hands. Interestingly, the creators of cyborgs have given them to us many times with a built-in value judgment. In other words, many cyborgs are cast as the bad guy thereby suggesting that mixing humans and machines is dangerous — cyborg villain Darth Vader comes to mind. But is using technology to improve upon nature really such a bad idea?
If the thought of a being who is half-human and half-machine seems disturbing, consider The Six Million Dollar Man, whose cyborg protagonist is a hunky crime-fighting hero. Colonel Steve Austin, a NASA astronaut who was badly injured in an accident and rebuilt by the government with bionic parts, captured the hearts and imagination of TV-viewers across the U.S. in the 1970s, in part, because of his mechanical enhancements. In the 1970s, that premise seemed farfetched. Today the idea of a cyborg doesn’t seem impossible and bionic body parts already exist. In 2013, the U.S. approved Argus II the first bionic eye implant (coincidentally one of Colonel Austin’s bionic parts was his left eye). And Johns Hopkins University has developed a modular prosthetic limb which is the most lifelike arm prosthesis yet.
“When I think of technology and the body, I think of that in multiple instances — my physical body, my mental body and also (kind of) this dissipated online existence.”
A discussion of technology and the body, though, extends far beyond talking about cyborgs and prosthetics. With advances in technology, one can argue that technology and the body have become inextricably intertwined (at least in first world countries) and the distinction between corporeal and mechanical blurs and bends with even the smallest surface scratch. So while cyborgs in the strictest sense are still fictional, human beings’ heavy reliance on technology today could be perceived as a mutated offspring or cousin of the cyborg. Kelly Sears, an experimental animator and University of Colorado professor who prompted Tilt West’s roundtable discussion, described this nuanced blurring of lines between the body and technology in several ways. As she introduced the topic, Ms. Sears told the group, “When I think of technology and the body, I think of that in multiple instances — my physical body, my mental body and also (kind of) this dissipated online existence.” She added, “I’m very interested in how the use of multiple selves overlap and are present and active at the same time.” This juggling of multiple selves is not an entirely modern phenomenon, but modernity and technology raise a multitude of new questions worthy of serious discussion.
During a recent episode of the NPR show “Fresh Air,” author and New York University professor Adam Atler described a survey of young adults in which 46% said that they would rather break a bone than lose their phone. It’s a startling statistic and one that reflects on the very nature of how blurred the line between technology and the body has become, and how attached we as humans have become to our various technology personas. Would a week without Instagram really be as bad as breaking a bone? Are we so attached to our online selves that we would suffer physical pain for them?
In the interview, Mr. Atler shared his ardent interest in the survey participants’ struggle with a seemingly straightforward question. Their responses weren’t always cut and dry — it was a very difficult decision for many. Some of those who ultimately chose a broken bone rather than losing their phone reasoned that at least they would have their phone during recovery. Based on their explanation, it’s easy to believe that these individuals view their phone as a part of their body. In fact, they consider their phone an important part of their body, more important it seems than some of their bones. What are we to make of that?
To give you an idea of how rapidly technology and our use of online personas have become ingrained in the daily habits of individuals, let’s look at some statistics. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2005 only 5% of adults in the U.S. used social media but by 2011 that number was 50%; today it is 69%. And those numbers don’t take into account American youth who have grown up spending more time with technology than in many cases the outdoors. In 2015, the Pew Research Center also reported that 24% of teens admitted to being online “almost constantly” and 92% of teens were online daily. While there are undoubtedly positives and negatives to so much screen time, one thing seems constant — our uncertainty as to whether such heavy reliance upon technology is good for us.

Reflecting upon this uncertainty, a roundtable participant and self-professed technology junkie confessed that his bias had always been in favor of the advantages technology brings. However, after reading several articles to prepare for the discussion, his vantage point had shifted. He wondered as many others did if so much technology was a good or bad thing. This brought up the question: Why do we feel compelled to place a positive or negative value on how technology impacts us?
During the hour and a half round table, participants shared countless concerns and interests in issues beyond online personas. As the discussion around the implications of an increasingly intricate relationship between technology and the body progressed, participants talked about racially segregated marketing, relationships between humans and robots, technology as language, boredom and its opposite busyness, technology-induced anxiety, technology-led meditation, e-waste, and the very definition of body and technology. As well, these topics were examined from different points of view — parent, citizen, teacher, student, significant other, professional, etc. In her prompt, Ms. Sears explained that a large part of her job as a professor is working with students to “interrogate the bodies of representations built into their work deconstructing normative impulses and biases with regard to representations of race, gender, religion and other identities.” And so, this too was reflected in the discussion in many ways such as the notion of a robot as a form of gender identity. One participant had recently polled her students and discovered that the majority approved of a relationship between a human and a robot. From their perspective, one could deconstruct conventional notions of gender and view a robot as a form of gender expression.
Turning the topics over and over while carefully considering the relationship between technology and the body, the group ultimately achieved Ms. Sears’s goal of producing “less utopic/dystopic binaries” and instead offered “navigational guides and strategic detours.” Through thoughtful discussion, participants were pushed to think more deeply and reserve judgment instead seeking information and understanding. Clearly, as Ms. Sears suggested, technology and the body “exists in smaller brush strokes.” Cyborgs, online personas, and the many other ways that technology and the body are interlaced aren’t good or bad; they are as complicated and diverse and humans.

“If you aren’t getting rejected on a daily basis, then your goals aren’t ambitious enough.” —Chris Dixon, Internet Entrepreneur
A couple of years ago, a journalist friend of mine and I started joking on Twitter about which of us receives more rejections — I’m a poet, and felt confident that my writing was rejected more frequently than his. The joke between us eventually turned into “The Jerklife Rejects Club,” which is a small group of writer friends who share our rejection stories and stats, but also includes an element of competition — the writer with the most rejections at the end of the year “wins.” This story was the first thing that came to mind when I received an invitation to participate in Tilt West’s roundtable conversation on Rejection and Denial.
I started submitting my poetry for publication when I was in high school, which was always summarily rejected. One day, a form rejection letter I received included a handwritten note from the editor with her words of encouragement noting the lines that she enjoyed and the double-underlined phrase: Keep Writing!!! I was thrilled to receive this letter; I brought it with me to school the next day to show my Creative Writing teacher, Mrs. Onesty, and we both celebrated my progress. While it was still a rejection, it was accompanied by the hope of future acceptance.
“If I didn’t define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people’s fantasies for me and eaten alive.” —Audre Lorde, Author
Because I am biracial black and from Park Hill in Denver, rejection was a common part of my social existence as a child. While Park Hill was a diverse neighborhood, both racially and socioeconomically, most people fell squarely on one side of the line or another. My classmates and their families were not often prepared for a face or hair like mine, so obviously and decidedly both or neither or in-between. Their confusion about my lack of respect for the boundaries they believed in generally led to curt denial and rejection. Biraciality is a peculiar thing; I often joke that mixed people are the only ones who get to experience racism at their own family reunions. We learn the intricacies of acceptance and rejection from birth, our existence challenging people’s attachments to boxes and lines.
I learned early in life that I had the power to accept people, carefully cultivating a circle of extraordinary friends. By middle school, I decided that my self-acceptance was more important to me than the acceptance of my peers. By the time I reached my teen years, I was hardly able to give weight to anyone else’s denial or rejection. I also learned that I had the same capacity to reject people as anyone else, and became an expert in rejecting ideologies, expectations, and advances that I found oppressive or offensive, or that otherwise didn’t meet my needs.

“I am good at walking away. Rejection teaches you how to reject.” —Jeanette Winterson, Author
Since then, I have often employed these skills of acceptance and rejection as an editor, as a curator, and as a creative. I have rejected brilliant work that I absolutely LOVED when it wasn’t the best fit for a project. Similarly, I have accepted work that I personally disliked when it served the needs of a project. These experiences remind me that rejection doesn’t necessarily mean that my work does not have merit.
I am grateful that my life’s journey has allowed me to see from so many different perspectives, and has anchored me so deeply in my own. As a creative, my experience with rejection allows me to make whatever I need to, irrespective of other people’s boundaries. My voice is always the loudest one in my head, which allows me to create and share my work boldly, even when rejected by some.
“I really wish I was less of a thinking man and more of a fool not afraid of rejection.” —Billy Joel
During the conversation at Tilt West, our prompter and my friend Bobby LeFebre, in discussing the historical weight of rejection, said, “If you were ostracized, if you were castigated or denied or rejected, it usually was a death sentence, you know? We relied on one another to get through things. . . That emotional connection still lives in our bones, it’s still a part of who we are and we can’t really escape that.”

While many aspects of human life have evolved over the millennia, and we are now able to survive with almost no direct interaction with others, our tribal history is still a part of our innate nature. In this age of social media, we are more connected and disconnected than ever before, depending on your perspective, and the rate of rejection and denial we engage in and are subjected to is constantly expanding. We accept or deny friend requests; like, share, follow and unfollow; and find ourselves exposed to the acceptance or rejection of our networks every time we go online.
Coming together to share our thoughts about rejection and denial revealed a broad range of perspectives in our conversation. For some, a tender vulnerability came through, while others displayed a more callused indifference. While rejection was a common experience among all of the participants, it is not often a subject that we discuss because it is associated with so much fear and shame. Ultimately, I think we all agreed that rejection and denial are, like many things in life, best consumed in good company.